African Pentecostalism Has Given Birth To A New Breed Of Mentally Lazy Christians Who See God As A Rewarder Of Mediocrity
Kay Musonda
1 April 2017 |
Interesting article if you are undecided about the bad fruits of charismaticism.
African Pentecostalism Has Given Birth To A New Breed Of Mentally Lazy Christians Who See God As A Rewarder Of Mediocrity
Kay Musonda
1 April 2017 |
Interesting article if you are undecided about the bad fruits of charismaticism.
In hopes of seeing the greatest success, human prosperity, and spiritual blessedness among the women of the world, while at the same time refuting and guarding ourselves against those practices that have most uniformly degraded the female sex, we commit ourselves to the following principles.
In short, as a Christian feminist, I am a conservative Christian since that is the best way to help women.
_______________________
Why don’t those who call themselves feminists support the proposals that would most tend to the happiness of women?
Bad fruits should be expected from a bad tree. If our hearts are naturally inclined to sin, what kind of religion do you think we will invent?
“So every good tree bears good fruit, but the bad tree bears bad fruit.” Matt. 7:17
“Every plant which My heavenly Father did not plant shall be uprooted.” Matt. 15:13
ATR produces poverty.
“The Limited Good” is the economic theory of animism. Should we think about wealth as a bag of apples or as an apple tree? ATR commonly approaches wealth as if the apples were all taken out of the bag or violently taken from their hands. Now they have no hope, except some form of stealing such as political revolution, socialism, or crime in order to enjoy prosperity. This is the default—not explicit—worldview of ATR. Why are people so quick to be jealous of others who have more? Why are they so hopeless about their own poverty? The religion does not have moral laws about planning and work because it does not have a God who planned the world and governs it providentially.
In fact, a Tsonga proverb illustrates ATR’s contribution to poverty: “Vusiwana i vuloyi.” (Poverty is witchcraft.) The religion has a direct tie to the economic status of the people. As Christians, should we not expect false religions to produce poverty? Does not the book of Proverbs promise wealth in accordance to Christian virtues such as hard work, planning, and patience? Yes, criminals or greedy politicians may hinder someone who is obeying the commands of Proverbs, but as long as it is not hindered by other people’s sins, the religion of Jesus Christ does eventually produce wealth.
ATR promotes ignorance.
As an adherent to the traditions, life’s goals are entirely focused on this world, so there is “no impulse for any higher life” from this religion. (Abraham Kuyper, Lectures on Calvinism, delivered in 1898, reprint 1931, page 35.) The religion cannot answer the main questions of humanity.
These philosophical inquiries cause men to write and think and advance, yet ATR has no mechanism to even treat with the great ideas.
ATR has has no texts so it is inherently non-intellectual. Why were there no schools, writing, books, or science 300 years ago? Why are there no bookstores today in areas influenced primarily by ATR in the past? As someone who works with language with more than a passing interest, the orthography of Tsonga, Venda, or Shona are amazing accomplishments. Those first missionaries took sounds out of the air and produced an alphabet and phonics so that African thoughts could be recorded. They labored for years at this task producing dictionaries and textbooks so that the people could read the Christian Bible and be saved from the impoverishing demons of ATR.
ATR prohibits discernment.
Discernment is a spiritual virtue, so we should expect Satan to discourage this work (1 Cor. 2:15). ATR transfers to all knowledge a changeful, fickle character because the religion has no final authority above all others. Science is impossible because no single, great Spirit made the world by laws that reflect His character. Philosophy and theology are impossible because contradictions are not necessarily wrong. It is only wrong to steal if you get caught. Logically this means: It is wrong to steal, and it is not wrong to steal. It is only wrong to lie if you hurt someone that you did not want to hurt. History is not important because the nature of mankind can change and the future may not be like the past anyway. It is a way of viewing life and the world that sinks the soul over centuries into a dank mental prison. This is what we would expect from a false religion since the job of a missionary is to “turn them from darkness to light and from the power of Satan to God (Acts 26:18).”
ATR propagates dictators.
Those who write historical accounts of African states often blame the problems on leadership. When the country breathes easily after one dictator is deposed, the man who brought them freedom from the last tyranny commonly turns out the same or worse. It is superficial to finger the leaders as if an epidemic of bad leaders caused itself. As Christianity produces all goodness, truth, and beauty in society, so we should expect that false religion will produce all badness, falsehood, and ugliness.
ATR promotes power as a virtue irrespective of moral safeguards. Who is the quintessential Zulu still remembered with airports and public attractions named in his honor? The same man who waged brutal wars against the Ndebele and Shangaan (Tsonga) people, Shaka (to say nothing of his aggression against the Afrikaaners and Englishmen). Since the religion has no recorded teachings, it has no unchanging moral restraints. Once grown in this garden, kings naturally strive for all the power they can achieve. By lack of religious prohibition, ATR fertilizes and waters the latent lust for control in the heart of men.
Africa’s problems come largely from their false religion.
What then should our attitude be toward ATR?
This cycle has already happened in Europe. Evidence of superstitions and polytheism come from most countries including England when Julius Caesar arrived and Germany after Boniface. ATR has been a tool working against the people who follow it—a vicious circle. As the “futile way of life inherited from your forefathers” ATR bears the responsibility for most of the poverty, ignorance, and failure of this continent. If we would all fight African poverty, we must fight this false religion, and for this task, our weapons are not carnal. Churchplanting, evangelistic, prayerful, discerning missionaries are the great enemies of African Traditional Religion and the only enduring hope—in God’s usual means of grace—for Africa.
Other articles in the series on African Traditional Religion:
African Traditional Religion 1: Africa’s God
African Traditional Religion 2: The Gods Never Sleep
African Traditional Religion 3: Similarities with World Religions
African Traditional Religion 4: African Christianity has the Same Theology as ATR.
African Traditional Religion 5: ATR is Uniquely Used by Satan
As a general category, southern Africa calls itself Christian. In Jason Mandryk’s 2010 edition of Operation World here are the numbers of people who claim to be Christian in southern African countries.
Yet overwhelmingly this “Christianity” is a strain of the theological disease from the Prosperity family. After many years of evangelism, I have found it much easier to find an African “Christian” who believes he must “speak prosperity over his job” than to find one who speaks of the Son of God dying for his sins. I have heard numerous preachers on TV, books, and rural crusades tell their audiences that they have power to create reality like a god, but I have never heard even one speak merely about the themes around God giving righteousness to wicked men by faith in Christ. I have heard a “pastor” say that “It’s boring in Heaven.”
African Christianity is a fatal mixture of ATR with Christian terms. It is not like mixing a bowl of mashed potatoes with a sprinkling of cyanide—potentially deadly to some. Rather think of it as offering an ice-cold glass of bleach or drain cleaner with a half-teaspoon of sugar to improve the taste.
This kind of dilution between two religions is called syncretism. History and Scripture offers many examples. God’s chosen people were often syncretistic.
He took this from their hand, and fashioned it with a graving tool and made it into a molten calf; and they said, “This is your god, O Israel, who brought you up from the land of Egypt. 5 Now when Aaron saw this, he built an altar before it; and Aaron made a proclamation and said, “Tomorrow shall be a feast to the Lord.” Exodus 32:4-5
So while these nations feared the Lord, they also served their idols; their children likewise and their grandchildren, as their fathers did, so they do to this day. 2 Kings 17:41
In the NT, Simon the Sorcerer tried to mix his traditional voodoo beliefs with Christianity. He “believed” and was baptized, and yet he loved power and thought God was for sale (Acts 8:12-22).
Syncretism is common in Brazil where they mix traditional animism and Catholicisim. In North Africa, Islam is commonly blended with ATR creating “folk Islam.” The ancient Romans did not mind adding gods to their religion as long as the Emperor maintained the highest authority.
Syncretism fits with ATR. Like many false religions, ATR can absorb other religious ideas without changing much because they have no absolute standard. There is no law in ATR requiring men to speak the truth because they have no Christ who says, “I am the Truth.” The earliest Venda kings who had contact with Christianity eventually acquiesced to allow the new religion as long as they could keep their own customs and religions. The earliest missionary efforts among the Vendas were constantly met with syncretism (See Kirkaldy’s first chapter). Today, many men are pastors, but they still share a fear of spirits, and their ministries are often dominated by discussions of what the spirits have done, and how to get around the spirits. (The majority of books by African pastors that I have seen all are dominated by discussions of spirits.) Their public teaching centers on freedom from the spirits and their efforts to impoverish the common man. Just turn on a religious TV show from this continent and you won’t have to listen very long.
Prosperity theology is largely syncretistic. As ATR deals with issues affecting this life, so too does prosperity theology.
Prosperity preachers shot out Christian words, but they have changed the sum and substance of the religion in order to fit it with the useless way of life they received from their forefathers (1 Pet. 1:18). This is the most common kind of Christianity in southern Africa today, but it is really just ATR with new clothes. The glasses have not been changed. The worldview is largely left untouched. The same fears of witchcraft, voodoo, and evil spirits still dominate daily experience. Now the witchdoctors simply wear suits, carry Bibles, and shout “Hallelujah.”
Syncretism is not Christian. In Bunyan’s Holy War Mr. Loath-to-Stoop comes out to negotiate with Emmanuel offering 8 different compromises, yet the Golden Prince rejects them all. He will have all or none.
“So then, none of you can be My disciple who does not give up all his own possessions.” Luke 14:33
Peter said that Simon was bound in sin, needed forgiveness, and would die because of his syncretism (Acts 8:20-23). Mark Minnick captures the heart of Isaiah’s message with this syncretism-damning summary of the book of Isaiah: “Trust only in the Holy One of Israel, for He alone is salvation.” Syncretism has no more saving faith than fornication has of true love.
Africa’s Christianity is not Christian because it is largely syncretistic.
Other articles in the series on African Traditional Religion:
African Traditional Religion 1: Africa’s God
African Traditional Religion 2: The Gods Never Sleep
African Traditional Religion 3: Similarities with World Religions
African Traditional Religion 4: African Christianity has the Same Theology as ATR.
African Traditional Religion 5: ATR is Uniquely Used by Satan
Myanmar, known in the past as Burma, has about as many people as South Africa (around 55 million), though the country is half the size. The majority, 80-90%, of the people are Buddhist. Only about 8% have any Christian conviction. Yet over 1 million are Baptists. Where did they come from? They all trace their roots back to a 23-year old man and his 22-year old wife who arrived 204 years ago. (July 1813) We should know these people, these fellow travellers because they deserve to be imitated. “Remember those who led you, who spoke the word of God to you; and considering the result of their conduct, imitate their faith.” Hebrews 13:7
The two books I used the most for this biography are Courtney Anderson’s To the Golden Shore and Arabella Stuart’s The Lives of the Three Mrs. Judsons, the edition published by PBP since it has nearly 150 pages of extra material. This manuscript was intended for the ear not the eye, thus, the choppy sentences.
The Life of Adoniram Judson
“I have now to ask whether you can consent to part with your daughter early next spring, to see her no more in this world ? Whether you can consent to her departure to a heathen land, and her subjection to the hardships and sufferings of a missionary life? Whether you can consent to her exposure to the dangers of the ocean; to the fatal influence of the southern climate of India; to every kind of want and distress; to degradation, insult, persecution, and perhaps a violent death? Can you consent to all this, for the sake of Him who left His heavenly home and died for her and for you; for the sake of perishing, immortal souls; for the sake of Zion and the glory of God? Can you consent to all this, in hope of soon meeting your daughter in the world of glory, with a crown of righteousness brightened by the acclamations of praise which shall resound to her Saviour from heathens saved, through her means, from eternal woe and despair?”
“God saw it was necessary… to strip us of our only little all. O may it not be vain that he has done it. May we so improve it, that he will stay his hand say, ‘It is enough.’”
“Some come from two or three months’ journey, from the borders of Siam and China—‘Sir, we hear that there is an eternal hell. We are afraid of it. Do give us a writing that will tell us how to escape it.’ Others come from the frontiers of Kathay, a hundred miles north of Ava. … Others come from the interior of the country, where the name of Jesus Christ is a little known—‘Are you Jesus Christ’s man? Give us a writing that tells us about Jesus Christ.’”
Eight Lessons From the Lives of the Judson’s
Conclusion
Similarities between ATR and all other false religions.
ATR has many gods like Hinduism or the spiritism of South America. (Some sources do claim that ATR reveres one god at the top of all the other gods. However, all the sources agree that ATR promotes the fear of many spirits with god-like powers. Contrast that with the Christian duty to fear only Jehovah. Luke 12:4-5; Proverbs 1:7)
Like Buddhism and all forms of animism, ATR searches the spiritual world for causes of phenomena in the physical world.
Like the prosperity religion, ATR emphasizes health, comfort, and wealth.
Like all other religions, ATR attempts to take into account the broad scope of everything in the world. Unfortunately, the theological structure of ATR can only stutter out a unity based on mutable, fickle spirits for treating birth, growth, life with others, work, and death.
Similarities between ATR and the one true religion of Jesus Christ.
The gods of ATR affect all areas of life as Jesus Christ places His feet over all of life. 1 Cor. 10:31
The gods of ATR are personal like the one true God, not like the impersonal “deity” in Buddhism.
The gods of ATR make certain demands, and they require a sacrifice when their demands are not met.
The gods of ATR must be feared and respected like the One who said, “Fear Him who can destroy both soul and body in Hell.”
All religions share important similarities. And aren’t short chapters a breath of fresh air?
Other articles in the series on African Traditional Religion:
African Traditional Religion 1: Africa’s God
African Traditional Religion 2: The Gods Never Sleep
African Traditional Religion 3: Similarities with World Religions
African Traditional Religion 4: African Christianity has the Same Theology as ATR.
African Traditional Religion 5: ATR is Uniquely Used by Satan
Most people born in Africa before the 20th century received by default the glasses of African Traditional Religion with which they involuntarily came to know the world. For many today the world is still colored by those old lenses. In ATR, the gods are concerned mostly about physical actions and not theoretical beliefs. Nearly every bad thing that happens can be blamed on a spirit, yet I have not heard people praising the swikwembu when good things happen. This is what we would expect since Paul marks ingratitude as a mark of pagan religion (Rom. 1:21).
“[ATR] is purely eudemonistic, the religious ceremonies having as their sole aim material benefits connected with the terrestrial life, e. g. abundance, health, peace, and good sleep!”
Junod, vol. 2, 428.“Since people often fear death and witchcraft they look for means by which to strengthen or increase their life-force. There are different kinds of amulets which people trust in believing that by these they will counteract the work of witchcraft. Some of those amulets are pieces of cloth or wood or metal. Many members of the ZCC regard their star badge as this kind of thing. I once took away one of those badges from one of the workers at our hospital and the next day he came to me asked for it back. He said: ‘Please give it back to me, I didn’t sleep at all last night. I’m very ill because you’ve taken away this protector of my body.’ Another man told me that when he has that star, that badge, even ghosts and evil spirits are afraid to come near him.”
Van Rooy, Koos. “Word for Africa” Institute for Reformational Studies, 1990, page 11.
The gods have physical power, but they do not rule or govern the world by laws. Thus, we are doomed to living in a capricious world—experiences on earth do not conform to a great, single purpose. Storms, floods, earthquakes, epidemics, and poverty are somehow attributed to the spirits working together. Though the spirits are believed to be always doing, the causes can never be certainly or precisely determined because they do not observe settled laws or constant natures that would anchor the world to a metaphysical rock. The Greeks saw that the world was constantly changing (Heraclitus, ca. 500 BC), but yet they also saw a timeless, unchanging element in the world (Parmenides, ca. 400 BC). Such glimmers of stabilizing grace as Parmenides bequeathed to his people, have been refused by ATR to those who are stuck in its millennia-long rut.
The gods expect obedience to traditions. Because ATR’s gods are ancestors, they require adherence to the “old ways.” The way things were done when they were alive. Since these ways are passed down orally and not literally, they are constantly changing. Notice the differences between Shona, Zulu, and Venda taboos. Just as their languages began together and have slowly drifted apart, so too have their traditions.
Some examples that are still common among different Bantu language groups:
So, tradition rules, yet this authority is inconsistent since many traditions, blowing in the winds of an oral culture, slowly change over time.
The gods hear and answer prayer. The “thabelo” or “xikhongelo” word groups are common summaries for all religious duties in ATR. How many times have we heard someone describe all church serves or religious activity as “xikhongelo” (prayer)? The spirits keep active by answering prayer according to their abilities and moods. In this way, they mediate between the living and the invisible powers. Since bad things often happen in a sinful world, the common man finds an abundant store of reasons to believe in witchcraft.
Rather than seeing pain and problems as a result of sinful choices by responsible people, ATR catechizes its adherents with a tremendous fear of the ever-active spirits who are usually involved in the bad, painful things of life.
Other articles in the series on African Traditional Religion:
African Traditional Religion 1: Africa’s God
African Traditional Religion 2: The Gods Never Sleep
African Traditional Religion 3: Similarities with World Religions
African Traditional Religion 4: African Christianity has the Same Theology as ATR.
African Traditional Religion 5: ATR is Uniquely Used by Satan
“What comes into our minds when we think about God is the most important thing about us.” (A. W. Tozer, The Knowledge of the Holy) We all wear mental “glasses” that control what we think about God. Most of us are not aware of these glasses—our worldview, or presuppositions. What are the presuppositions (assumptions) that are common in Africa?
African traditional religion (ATR) is a theological system that controlled the mindset of much of Africa for hundreds or even thousands of years. There is no “single” system of ATR since its teachings have never been written down. They do not have temples, houses of worship, holy days, or teachings. All of this can beg the question, “Is ATR then a religion?” Yes, because ATR or animism is the name given to the beliefs and actions that traditionally have governed Africans’ passions and religious devotion. Scripture describes all false religion in 1 Pet. 1:18: “futile way of life inherited from your forefathers,” Yet these old ways determine how the majority of a billion souls hear the gospel today.
I welcome the insights from any readers and especially from Africans who can cast more light on this subject.
In African traditional religion, God is a collection of unknowable, fickle spirits who have differing powers that they use for and against us, often at the request of our enemies, during our entire lives.
God is gods. In ATR, there are many gods.
“…[the Vhavenda] also venerate and pray to their ancestors like gods.”
Wessman, Reinhold. Journals and private papers stored in the Berlin Missionary Society, 1889. Quoted in Kirkaldy, Alan, Capturing the Soul: The Vhavenda and the Missionaries. 2005, page 176. At least 9 other times, the first missionaries referred to the original Vhavenda as worshipping multiple spirits.“Any man who has departed this earthly life, becomes a shikwembu, a god. … Since every human being becomes a shikwembu at death, there are consequently many categories of these. … The two great categories of gods are those of the family, and those of the country, the latter being those of the reigning family. … Moreover, each family has two sets of gods, those on the father’s side and those on the mother’s, those of “kweru” and those of “bakokwana.”
Junod, Henri. The Life of a South African Tribe, 1926, vol. 2, page 374.Mankhelu, an Nkuna n’anga with deep knowledge of both Tsonga and Pedi customs says, “The village of my mother is as the home of the gods. (ka mamana hi ko psikwembyen).”
Mankhelu wa ka Shiluvane, died in 1908. Quoted in Junod, vol. 1, page 268.
These gods are the collection of family ancestors who have died in the past. Even in books written by Africans, they constantly mention the effect that unknown spirits and spirits from past generations have on us today.
Mike Maimele, a pastor writes, “So, as a force in the earth, you enter an environment that is already occupied by other forces, some of which are in opposition to you. … It happens everywhere and to everyone. … “evil spirits” et. al. (Dealing with Gangsterism in Your Life. 2008, pages 2, 3, 6, and throughout.)
Many pastors commonly speak about generational curses and spirits of “poverty,” “joblessness,” “barrenness,” and “failure.” Who keeps those curses in force? Where do all these competing spirits come from? ATR is as polytheistic as Greece with its Pantheon (Acts 17:16, 22-23), Egypt with her gods (Ex. 12:12), and Abraham’s ancestors with their “gods.” (Josh. 24:15) Polytheism is the soul’s natural response when darkened by sin yet still feeling the impulses toward God that are woven into each nook and cranny of creation.
Worshipping many gods is called polytheism. Animism is a particular kind of polytheism where the “gods” are constantly influencing the world in which we live. ATR is both polytheistic and animistic. When someone wearing these glasses hears about the Christian God, they tend to include Him within their group of previous gods. “Oh, I know what gods are, so this new God must be basically similar to these other ones.”
The world is populated with invisible spirits, yet according to ATR they are ultimately unknowable. As with most animistic religions, ATR has no sacred texts or writings that tell about their gods. The Greeks had myths, but no book. All that can be known through revealed propositions such as Jesus statement, “I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life,” is locked away from those who inherit the glasses of ATR. We can’t know their reasons for acting as they do. We can’t know their names. We can’t know for sure what they love or hate. We can’t know the actions they have done, or the actions that are just natural consequences of men making bad choices. Junod writes that the theology of ATR is “very confused and even contradictory.” This perpetual ignorance produces a worldview of uncertainty and fear. Since knowledge is impossible about the most important part of life, then what hope can we have to know anything else?
The most far-reaching and damaging doctrine of ATR is the mutability of spirits. The gods are not absolute. Speaking about the religious beliefs, Junod writes that ATR is a “somewhat confused mass of religious ideas, and we must not look for anything logical and organic. We may even meet with contradictions, conflicting statements.” (Junod, vol. 2, 372.) Taboos can change. ATR requires that Africans must follow rituals around birth, circumicision, lobola, and death, but the customs may change from Pedi to Venda to Tsonga to European. The religion is as fluid as the unwritten language that serves to clothe it. Changeful gods mean that knowledge of causation and science are impossible. Why should anyone try to record the causes of someone’s sickness and death when they are sure that the death was caused by the whim of one of the spirits in answer to someone’s jealousy? What society would prosper in science if they didn’t first assume there were unchanging physical laws? Why should anyone think about political or moral philosophy if life is controlled by fickle, invisible, spirits rather than laws? Thus, ATR deserves the blame for the great poverty of the continent.
The gods are fallible. Since they cannot see everything, they can be tricked. Since they are not absolute their desires can be overturned in time or when a more powerful spirit arrives. They do not gain special wisdom after death, and there is no doctrine of omniscience. So, ATR’s view of providence is capricious and untethered to any transcendent skill.
ATR has many gods who are really the spirits of those who have died before us. Rarely is the connection between natural condition and primitive religion more clearly seen. This theology is as bad as the poverty and social ills of the continent.
Other articles in the series on African Traditional Religion:
African Traditional Religion 1: Africa’s God
African Traditional Religion 2: The Gods Never Sleep
African Traditional Religion 3: Similarities with World Religions
African Traditional Religion 4: African Christianity has the Same Theology as ATR.
African Traditional Religion 5: ATR is Uniquely Used by Satan